Brexit could mean Britain takes a bite of #Appletax

Author: Aaron Dhillon
The European Competition Commission has ruled that “Ireland granted illegal tax benefits to Apple” leaving the company facing an eye-watering €13 billion (£11.1 billion) tax bill. 

This selective tax treatment is considered illegal as it provides Apple a significant advantage over businesses that are subject to the same national taxation rules. Ireland must now recover the unpaid taxes in Ireland from Apple for the years 2003 to 2014. Plus interest. 

In fact, the tax treatment in Ireland enabled Apple to avoid taxation on almost all profits generated by sales of Apple products in the entire EU Single Market. This is due to Apple's decision to record all sales in Ireland rather than in the countries where the products were sold. 

Tax is complicated particularly in the modern, globalised economy so understanding Apple’s tax structure in Europe may shed some light on the Commission’s decision. 

Apple Inc, in the US, is the top brass, the Big Kahuna. Apple Inc owns two smaller companies based in Ireland - Apple Sales International (ASI) and Apple Operations Europe. 

These Irish companies hold the rights to use Apple's IP to sell Apple products outside America under a 'cost-sharing agreement'. They make yearly payments to Apple Inc to fund research and development efforts conducted on their behalf. In 2011 these payments amounted to about $2 billion and significantly increased in 2014. These payments are deducted from the profits recorded by these two companies in Ireland each year, in line with applicable rules. So far, so good.

ASI is responsible for buying Apple products from manufacturers and selling these products in Europe, Middle East, Africa and India. Customers don’t buy their products from the shops that physically sell them, rather from ASI itself. In this way Apple recorded all sales, and the profits stemming from these sales, directly in Ireland.

And this is where it gets interesting…

Two rulings by the Irish tax authorities, in 1991 and 2007, endorsed an allocation of profits away from Ireland to a “head office” within ASI, and this "head office" was not based in any country and did not have any employees or own premises. Its activities consisted solely of occasional board meetings (a nice example of transfer pricing). Therefore, only a small percentage of ASI’s profits were taxed in Ireland.

In 2011, ASI recorded profits of $22 billion with only approximately €50 million considered taxable in Ireland, leaving nearly €16 billion of profits untaxed. As a result, ASI paid less than €10 million of corporation tax in Ireland in 2011. In subsequent years, ASI’s recorded profits continued to increase but the profits considered taxable in Ireland under the terms of the tax rulings did not. 

Apple’s response has been unequivocal with CEO, Tim Cook, insisting that the company is “not a tax dodger” and declaring that the Commission’s decision is “an effort to rewrite Apple’s history in Europe, ignore Ireland’s tax laws and upend the international tax system in the process" which will ultimately “have a profound and harmful effect on investment and job creation in Europe.”

Cook’s indictment may well prove poignant as it’s been rumoured that Britain could be the big winner from this particular tax feud. Indeed this ruling is the conclusion of a two-year investigation and following landmark cases against Starbucks and Fiat and probes into Google and Facebook/

A so-called hard Brexit for Britain, going it alone and not remaining a part of the single market, would mean state aid rules would no longer constrain UK tax policy. A more favourable rate could be implemented regardless of the terms of negotiating Brexit as tax regimes are set at member state level (despite proposals for a Common Consolidate Corporate Tax Base that have been tabled since 2011). This would mean that the UK could position itself as a more attractive destination than Ireland, the Netherlands and Luxembourg, where the majority of the biggest US tech companies are headquartered, away from the growing stranglehold of state aid laws and EU Commission, which both the Irish government and the US Treasury have accused of trying to influence tax policy.

Regardless, in today’s increasing global economy, the practice of taxing profits earned in one country but reporting them in tax havens through the use of contrived corporate structures seems obsolete - surely reform and massive simplification of global tax bases is the only viable solution for the future.
08/09/16
posts

Related articles

Your business, tax and the environment
Your business, tax and the environment

Teaser

Financial Services

Content Type

General

14/01/22

Summary

Can tax be used to incentivise meaningful corporate environmental responsibility? Recent research has shown that of 405 recorded extreme weather events, 70% of them were made worse by human-cau

Teaser

Can tax be used to incentivise meaningful corporate environmental responsibility?

Read full article
Andy Craven

by

Andy Craven

Andy Craven

by

Andy Craven

Our partnership with The Women in Governance, Risk & Compliance Series
Our partnership with The Women in Governance, Risk & Compliance Series

Teaser

Financial Services

Content Type

General

26/10/21

Summary

Supporting women in business has never been more important, especially with the devastating impact the pandemic has had on the workforce over the last two years.The Women in Governan

Teaser

Supporting women in business has never been more important, especially with the devastating impact the pandemic has had on the workforce over the last two years.

Read full article
Ruksana Uddin

by

Ruksana Uddin

Ruksana Uddin

by

Ruksana Uddin

Roles in demand across Specialist Markets
Roles in demand across Specialist Markets

Teaser

Professional Services

Content Type

General

06/10/20

Summary

2020 has been an unexpected year across the world, and it has been crucial to monitor and deal with all the effects of the Covid pandemic in business and in our personal lives. Amidst this crisis we h

Teaser

Amidst this crisis we have also had the uncertainty surrounding Brexit looming over us, which has left many businesses trying to deal with the immediate challenges to society and the economy at large.

Read full article
David Clamp

by

David Clamp

David Clamp

by

David Clamp

jobs

Related jobs

Tax Manager

Salary:

£42,000 - £44,000 per annum

Location:

Bury, Greater Manchester

Industry

Business Services

Qualification

None specified

Market

Financial Services

Salary

£40,000 - £50,000

Job Discipline

Tax

Contract Type:

Permanent

Description

.

Reference

BBBH180466

Expiry Date

01/01/01

Aleksandra  Taranovskaja Find out more
Group Tax Manager

Salary:

£55,000 - £70,000 per annum

Location:

West Yorkshire

Industry

Business Services

Qualification

Fully qualified

Market

Financial Services

Salary

£70,000 - £80,000

Job Discipline

Tax

Contract Type:

Permanent

Description

Group Tax Manager for a leading Financial Services business based in West Yorkshire

Reference

BBBH180443

Expiry Date

01/01/01

Andy Craven

Author

Andy Craven
Andy Craven

Author

Andy Craven
Find out more
Senior Manager - Tax

Salary:

Negotiable

Location:

London

Industry

Consumer & Retail

Qualification

Fully qualified

Market

Commerce & Industry

Salary

£80,000 - £100,000

Job Discipline

Tax

Contract Type:

Permanent

Description

A luxury, reputable and fast-growing multi-channel retail business is currently seeking their next hire to join the London finance team.

Reference

BBBH180393

Expiry Date

01/01/01

Hannah Spears

Author

Hannah Spears
Find out more
Assistant VAT Manager

Salary:

£40,000 - £45,000 per annum

Location:

Leeds, West Yorkshire

Industry

Business Services

Qualification

None specified

Market

Financial Services

Salary

£40,000 - £50,000

Job Discipline

Tax

Contract Type:

Permanent

Description

.

Reference

BBBH180402

Expiry Date

01/01/01

Aleksandra  Taranovskaja Find out more
Corporate Tax Accountant (4 month contract)

Salary:

Up to £400 per day

Location:

London

Industry

Investment Banking & Capital Markets

Qualification

Fully qualified

Market

Financial Services

Salary

£350 - £450

Job Discipline

Tax

Contract Type:

Contract

Description

Corporate Tax Accountant (4-6 month contract)

Reference

BBBH178574

Expiry Date

01/01/01

Paul Roche

Author

Paul Roche
Paul Roche

Author

Paul Roche
Find out more
R&D Tax Manager

Salary:

Negotiable

Location:

Manchester, Greater Manchester

Industry

Professional Services

Qualification

None specified

Market

Financial Services

Salary

£60,000 - £70,000

Job Discipline

Tax

Contract Type:

Permanent

Description

.

Reference

BBBH180391

Expiry Date

01/01/01

Aleksandra  Taranovskaja Find out more
Tax Analyst

Salary:

£50,000 - £60,000 per annum

Location:

London

Industry

Transport & Logistics

Qualification

None specified

Market

Commerce & Industry

Salary

£60,000 - £70,000

Job Discipline

Tax

Contract Type:

Permanent

Description

Tax Analyst Required ASAP for a well established transport group!

Reference

BBBH180345

Expiry Date

01/01/01

Jaden Alie

Author

Jaden Alie
Jaden Alie

Author

Jaden Alie
Find out more
SENIOR TAX MANAGER

Salary:

€90,000 - €120,000 per annum

Location:

Amsterdam, North Holland

Industry

Professional Services

Qualification

Fully qualified

Market

Commerce & Industry

Salary

£100,000 - £125,000

Job Discipline

Tax

Contract Type:

Permanent

Description

Momenteel zijn wij voor een internationaal advocatenkantoor in Amsterdam op zoek naar een Senior Manager Tax. Deze rol is de brug tussen Partners en Consultant binnen het team van ruim 35 Fiscalisten

Reference

BBBH178239

Expiry Date

01/01/01

Guido Buwalda

Author

Guido Buwalda
Find out more
SENIOR TAX MANAGER

Salary:

€90,000 - €110,000 per annum

Location:

Amsterdam, North Holland

Industry

Professional Services

Qualification

Fully qualified

Market

Commerce & Industry

Salary

£80,000 - £100,000

Job Discipline

Tax

Contract Type:

Permanent

Description

Voor een fiscaal boutique firm in Amsterdam ben ik op zoek naar een Senior Tax Manager. Het kantoor bestaat uit 15 (ervaren) Fiscalisten en wordt aangestuurd door 3 Partners met een BIG 4 achtergrond

Reference

BBBH178229

Expiry Date

01/01/01

Guido Buwalda

Author

Guido Buwalda
Find out more
Indirect Tax Manager

Salary:

£450 - £475 per day

Location:

City of London, London

Industry

Media & Communications

Qualification

Fully qualified

Market

Commerce & Industry

Salary

£350 - £450

Job Discipline

Tax

Contract Type:

Permanent

Description

Indirect Tax Manager - Media - Immediate Start - Central London- Corporate Tax, advisory and indirect tax experience are a must

Reference

CMDN9932

Expiry Date

01/01/01

Kelvin Murphy

Author

Kelvin Murphy
Find out more
View all jobs